Authenticity v. Christianity (Updated)

They almost rhyme.  And I believe that they should be synonymous.  So why is it that they often seem to contradict one another?

I was talking with a friend the other day about worship and  told him how sometimes it is a lot better for me if I just listen and don’t look at the people singing on stage.  He asked me why, and I told him it was because I couldn’t take them seriously a lot of the time because of their “church face”.  For those of you who don’t know what I mean, it consists of a combined expression of giddiness, serenity, and gravity, and it looks a little bit like this:

Church Face

Now before anyone gets up in arms against me here,  I fully realize that I have no way of knowing the genuineness of anyone’s worship.  Yes, that is between them and God.  And I also have zero problem with charismatic displays of worship.  That is not my point–if you feel it, you feel it, and who cares what anyone else thinks.

My point is that I often get the feeling that people are simply putting on a show.  They feel like they have to look and act a certain way in order to appear genuine in what they are doing.  My question is, why can’t they just be who they are, and let the Holy Spirit work?  For some people that may be running up and down the aisles shouting in tongues, and for others it may be sitting quietly in the corner and letting God speak to them.

I personally have felt like doing both of these things at different times, as well as everything in between.  And in the interest of full disclosure, I haven’t followed my own advice.  I grew up in a very conservative Lutheran church, and up to this point, I haven’t even been comfortable lifting up my hands (even when I felt like it) because I am worried I am going to look stupid.  So why is it that we always let ourselves get in the way of really worshiping (and representing) God?

My friend pointed out that many people don’t know who they are, and so they put on whatever front they feel is expected of them at any given point.  I think that’s a good point, but I also think that quite often, authenticity can be intimidating.  And it can also be offensive to some.

I was recently reading reviews of Donald Miller’s new book A Million Miles in a Thousand Years, a book I have not yet read.  As I usually do, I clicked on the lowest ratings to try to get a balanced view of things when I came across an interesting review.  You can find the review with comments here.  If any of you have not read Donald Miller before, he writes in autobiographical form, and talks about how his life’s journey has shaped his faith.  He is often sarcastic and self-deprecating, which I suppose could be misinterpreted at times.  But the point is that he is real.  He writes about what he really thinks and feels, regardless of how it may come across at times.  And that obviously offended this reviewer.

I guess what I’m really looking for is a way to make people comfortable with themselves as God has made them.  I think if we can find a way to make the church a safe place for authenticity it will lead to a greater connection with God, both on a personal and a corporate level.  I think it will also help change the outside perception of legalism and hypocrisy, much of which, I believe, is based on a façade put up by the church and its members.

I could probably write a book about this, so I’ll stop rambling and leave you with this question:  How do we drop the image and be genuine?  I’m still praying about that one. If you have any ideas, I’d love to hear them.


Here’s a great music video by the band Hockey that illustrates how authenticity and dropping your social guard can be contagious.  Cheesy, but fun.  And I’m not sure, but I think that kid might have learned how to dance by watching videos of me from high school.

For your viewing pleasure, click here.


2 thoughts on “Authenticity v. Christianity (Updated)

  1. you could write a book on this, huh? i don’t see author in the list below. (wink, wink, nudge, nudge, running fingers through hair, kiss) WHOA, wait a second! that went in a completely different direction then i thought it was going. man, i really need to see a therapist. “you see doc, when i was little i never was aloud to play with trucks, and ever since then…..”

    p.s. if professor and teacher are different, writer and author are different to ;-}

  2. Good writing, Andy. Encouragement is def. a lot harder to do than to bring someone down using negative comments. That is something I have been working on lately as well.

    In regards to your question…I also grew up in a Lutheran church and am now attending First Baptist in Arnold. Sometimes I feel like raising my hand but I have the thought of driving someone away from true worship through my hand raising. I also don’t want them to see me putting on a “show” and think of my previous sins-which I have many as we all do-and I don’t want people to see me doing that and think “oh that’s just Ryan’s church face.” I have never been a hand raiser, and sometimes other people that do it do distract me…but why should I judge? Only God knows the heart of a person during worship. So my response is probably just to close your eyes. It helps me because I can do what I feel led to do personally and don’t worry about what others think. If someone is led away from worship and can’t get back to true worship because of my following the Holy Spirit that is an issue they need to handle personally with God.

    Any further insight that you have send my way bro.

    Oh-and keep up the good writing!


Please, share your thoughts. No, really, I'm begging you.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s